Stew Mel Rugby















Dundee HSFP RFC vs Stew Mel, 15/1/05

  • Click here to jump to Riggers' Review
  • Click here to jump to Stew Mel Stats

Squad

The Stewart's Melville FP RFC team to play Dundee HSFP RFC at Mayfield on Saturday, kick off 2 pm, is:

15
Richard Borthwick
14
Gavin Sharp
13
Chris Bissett
12
Struan Samson
11
Jed Gordon
10
Graham Shiel
9
Euan Clark
1
Paul Wharakura (captain)
2
Shaun McMurchy
3
Stephan de Beer
4
Ben Leathes
5
Stephen Dalgleish
6
Nick Penny
7
Ross Rennie
8
Graham Lind
   
16
Richard Hood
17
Alex Clarke
18
Dougie Rycroft
19
David Warwick

Three changes from the team that was selected but never played against Haddington last weekend.

Struan Samson is available this week and returns in the No. 12 jersey at the expense of David Warwick. Sam Hendry has had to drop out, and is replaced at outside centre by Chris Bissett, with Jed Gordon stepping up from the bench to fill Jaffa's wing berth.

The pack are unchanged from last week.

Due to problems we may encounter with winds going over the Forth Road Bridge, we are meeting at 10.30 am for the bus to Dundee.

This is another crucial game for the boys, so it would be great to see as many supporters as possible joining us for what I'm sure will be another memorable road trip to and from the City of Discovery.


Riggers' Review

Dundee HSFP away, 15/1/05

Mayfield in Dundee has not exactly been a happy hunting ground of late for Stewart’s Melville and, with our patchy away form this season, confidence was not at its highest for the first fixture of 2005. So let’s make no bones about it - achieving an 11-8 win was a fantastic result for the club, and certainly answered a few questions that had been going through the mind regarding desire, commitment and heart after the last game at Murrayfield Wanderers.

Dundee HSFP away, 15/1/05

To be fair, we were assisted by the decision of the Dundee team to kick to the corner rather than take the points on three occasions and, with the game always looking like being tight, those were strange decisions to take. Certainly, the decision, with five minutes to go, to go for the lineout instead of taking the straightforward three points on offer was one that we may have cause to be thankful for, if we can perform for the rest of this season. We certainly have reason to thank Ben Leathes, who decided to emulate what Justin Harrison did against the Lions in 2001 and steal the ball 5 metres out from our line.

Dundee HSFP away, 15/1/05

I think the healthy crowd appreciated the tough encounter that was served up between two well matched teams and, certainly, the gracious Dundee supporters and committee seemed to indicate that we were worth the victory, if only just. The hospitality at Dundee was, once again, first class and great to experience from a leading Scottish club. The generous donation of raffle prizes including whisky, cider and red wine for our bus trip home was very gratefully received by members of the team and some management!

Dundee HSFP away, 15/1/05

We return to Inverleith next week to take on Jed-Forest in probably the biggest game the club have faced since the promotion battle with Edinburgh Accies in early 2003. The winners of the game will have nothing secured, but will take massive confidence into the remaining games. Jed-Forest were the only team to visit Inverleith on league business in 2004 and come away with the points, so we all know it will be tough. We were given a bit of a lesson by them earlier in the season down at Riverside Park, so another tough encounter looms.

Dundee HSFP away, 15/1/05

It would be great to see as many supporters down as possible to try and cheer the club on. The team appreciate your support and, with the Tsunami Appeal donation of gate receipts being carried forward to this encounter, there are many others who would appreciate your support, too.

Riggers


Stew Mel Stats

Result Won 8-11
Sequence 3-0, 3-3 (half time), 8-3, 8-6, 8-11
Tries Jed Gordon (66 mins)
Conversions None
Penalties Richard Borthwick 2 (40 & 55 mins)
Cards

Nick Penny and the home left winger yellowed on 57 minutes for their part in a fracas that erupted after Gav Sharp was taken out

Referee Norman Imlach of Grangemouth had a pretty solid game, though his touch judges threw the occasional wobbler
Single Sentence Summary A rock solid second half display saw us take the points against a physical Dundee side on a day when few of those watching can have expected us the win; while our backs struggled to get over the gain line at times, the pack were immense, especially in the set piece
Leading Lion

Our win was very much built on our lineout dominance, with Shaun throwing like a dream and Ben all but winning the match for us by stealing a Dundee throw on our line late in the second half. But let's go for Dalgy, who once again put in an awesome shift in the Boiler Room.

Bevvy Bulletin

The pre- and post-match hospitality at Dundee was as good as ever, with Deuchars IPA on tap and excellent (if somewhat underdone) pies. Special mention must be given to the home fans who donated their raffle prizes (a bottle of whisky, a bottle of red wine and 8 cans of Strongbow) to the Bus Bevvy fund. Nice one!

 

Return to 1st XV Fixtures page